This is something I wrote for something that came to nothing. I’m putting it up here to add it to my portfolio of writing wonderment…
The Good:
+ Incredibly thin and stylish design
+ Fast and lag free
+ Stunning 4.3” screen
+ Swype integration makes typing super quick
The Bad:
- Samsung’s UI isn’t for everyone
- Not as user friendly as iOS
There’s no denying the influence of Apple upon the Samsung Galaxy S2. Whether it’s too influential is a matter for Samsung and Apple’s lawyers to continue to debate, but to dismiss the S2 as a wannabe iPhone is to do it a serious disservice.
Weighing in at just 116 grams, and with a thickness of just 8.49mm (or 9.91 at its thickest point), the phone certainly turns heads. When you flip it over to expose the 4.3” screen, those heads will probably do another full 360 degree turn too, because the AMOLED Plus screen is clear and vibrant, even in bright sunshine.
There’s no way of getting away from it: the Galaxy S2 is one seriously stylish looking bit of tech.
Look and feel
Imagine a Samsung engineer took a a rolling pin to the iPhone 4, then took a cheese-slicer to the resultant slightly fatter iPhone. If you tried this at home, other than a voided warranty, you’d theoretically have something resembling the Samsung Galaxy S2.
The front of the handset is dominated by the giant 4.3” screen, and beneath it is a single square home button. The other physical face buttons of earlier Android handsets are no longer present, though they are there in touch form. Pressing lightly either side of the home button illuminates the ‘back’ and ‘menu’ symbols, ready for use. Other than that, there’s a front facing two megapixel camera for video chat, and an embossed silver Samsung logo.
Turning the phone over reveals a flat plastic battery cover and the phone’s main eight megapixel camera. The flimsy plastic battery cover is the only blot on the S2’s otherwise flawless aesthetics, but it’s a small concession to the incredible size that makes the phone truly eye catching.
Under the bonnet
The phone packs some serious punch too, with a 1.2Ghz dual core processor and 1GB RAM, it leaves almost all smartphones – including the iPhone 4 – in its dust. Apps open quickly, graphically intensive games run flawlessly and switching between screens is lag free.
Speaking of rival handsets, Samsung follows the lead of HTC and tries to cover up the less user friendly aspects of Android with its TouchWiz UI. In truth, it’s not as appealing or intuitive as HTC’s Sense UI, and it’s streets behind that of iOS, which it looks like it’s trying to emulate.
Apps and bundled software
By default, the homescreen is a series of icons, with some limited widgets. These go from left to right on seven screens, with the main phone functions sitting in an iOS style permanent dock. The dock cannot be dramatically changed without rooting the phone, and more bafflingly such simple functions as reordering the applications menu alphabetically has to be done manually, which will drive obsessively neat users mad.
Likewise, Samsung’s reasonably impressive voice input software Vlingo also can’t be disabled without rooting. The software is designed to dictate notes and perform tasks through verbal instruction, for when you’re driving or just too lazy to use your fingers. Here Android’s advantages come into play as it’s integrated throughout the phone, unlike on iOS where as a third party app, it would be locked out of most core functions. The trouble is that Vlingo is activated by double tapping the home button, something that’s remarkably easy to do by mistake. On UK firmware, there’s no option to turn this off, and it’s all too easy to activate the piercing robotic voice that awaits your instruction.
More effective is Swype, which integrates with the whole Android system. This is a keyboard that predicts words by the lines you draw over the keyboard, allowing for lightning fast typing. It has to learn words like any other text program, but with a little use it’s hard to go back to the stock Android keyboard, without exclaiming a string of swear words that even the most efficient voice recognition software would struggle to decode.
Not all of the bundled software is welcome. There’s a lot of Samsung endorsed bloatware here including music, ebook and gaming hubs. To their credit, Samsung don’t attempt to block the official Google Marketplace, and the better apps that users will inevitably gravitate towards.
Multimedia
As you might expect from the praise for the screen, watching video and browsing websites on the S2 is an absolute pleasure. The quality of the image is maintained over a wide viewing angle too, ensuring you don’t need to be looking at the screen straight on to benefit from the image quality.
The built-in eight megapixel camera is another triumph for the handset, producing impressively detailed and colourful pictures. The software is easy to use, packed with options and with a simple interface to share any noteworthy photography on the fly.
You can also record video in 1080p, which is as crisp and smooth as you’d expect given the quality on display elsewhere. Serious film makers and photographers inevitably won’t be using it as a replacement camera, but it’s above the standard smartphone quality.
Phone functions and battery life
Then of course, there are its qualities as a phone. We’re pleased to report that the call quality of the S2 is fine, with conversations clear, even in windy and noisy environments.
Perhaps most pleasingly of all is how well the battery holds up for a light device with serious power, and such a large screen. While it’s not going to break the ‘nightly charge’ cycle of modern smartphones, we were initially concerned it would require a charger in your pocket. Even with live screensavers, we found we’d have between 50% and 20% charge remaining by nightfall.
Conclusions
While it comes at a premium price, there’s no doubt the Samsung Galaxy S2 is a premium product. Very few Android handsets come close to beating its performance and weight, and while it doesn’t deal a clear killer blow to the iPhone 4, Android enthusiasts will have plenty to support an argument that this is the best smartphone around right now.